—
Introduction: not all difficult behaviors are the same
When faced with a student with ADHD who disrupts the class, the teacher must make quick decisions. But the same outward appearance can mask very different realities. The child who fidgets in their chair, the one who breaks down in tears in front of an exercise, and the one who flatly refuses to work all exhibit “difficult” behaviors, but their causes and appropriate responses differ fundamentally.
Confusing these different types of behaviors leads to inappropriate, even counterproductive, interventions. Punishing a child in emotional crisis exacerbates their distress. Negotiating with a simply restless child teaches them that restlessness gives them power. Ignoring systematic opposition allows a harmful power dynamic to establish itself.
This ability to differentiate behaviors is a key skill for any adult supporting students with ADHD. It allows for targeted, effective, and respectful interventions. It also prevents the exhaustion generated by the blind application of inappropriate strategies.
This article proposes an analytical framework to distinguish between restlessness, emotional crisis, and opposition, understand their respective mechanisms, and adapt interventions accordingly.
—
Part One: Restlessness – the physiological need to move
Recognizing restlessness
Restlessness is characterized by constant body movement that does not seem related to a particular emotional situation or a deliberate refusal. The child fidgets, squirms, manipulates objects, rocks back and forth, taps their foot, without these movements indicating distress or an intention to disrupt.
The emotional state of the restless child is generally neutral or slightly positive. They do not seem to be suffering, nor do they express anger or sadness. Their face is relaxed, sometimes even smiling. They can be fully engaged in an activity while constantly moving.
Restlessness is relatively constant over time, with variations related to fatigue, the nature of the task, or the time of day, but without the sudden spikes characteristic of emotional crises. It constitutes the baseline state for many children with ADHD rather than a reaction to a specific event.
The restless child can generally respond to prompts appropriately. If asked a question, they respond coherently. If given an instruction, they can execute it while continuing to move. Movement does not prevent them from functioning cognitively.
The mechanisms of restlessness
Restlessness in ADHD primarily results from a neurological need for stimulation to maintain a sufficient level of cortical arousal. As we have seen in previous articles, the atypical dopaminergic system of these children drives them to seek external stimulation.
Movement serves as a form of self-stimulation that helps the brain maintain the activation necessary for attention. Paradoxically, preventing the child from moving can therefore hinder their concentration rather than improve it.
Restlessness can also reflect a difficulty in regulating arousal. The child oscillates between states of under-activation (drowsiness, disengagement) and over-activation (restlessness, excitement). Movement represents an attempt to find balance.
Finally, restlessness may result from a simple excess of physical energy that the child has not had the opportunity to expend. Sedentary school days accumulate motor tension that seeks to express itself.
How to respond to restlessness
The appropriate response to restlessness aims to channel it rather than suppress it.
Offering acceptable movement alternatives allows the need to be met without disrupting the class. Balance cushions, elastic bands under the chair, and quiet manipulatives provide appropriate outlets.
Integrating regular movement breaks into the daily schedule prevents excessive accumulation of motor tension. A few minutes of physical activity between work sequences recharge the containment capacities.
Avoid constant reminders to behave that interrupt the child without resolving the issue and deteriorate the relationship. If the movement does not significantly disrupt the environment, it can be tolerated.
Monitor for signs of escalation that would indicate a shift towards something other than simple restlessness. A sudden increase in activity level, a change in facial expression may signal an emotional crisis.
—
Part Two: Emotional crisis – the overflow of emotions
Recognizing the emotional crisis
The emotional crisis is characterized by a loss of control related to an emotional load that exceeds the child’s regulatory capacities. Unlike restlessness, it is triggered by an event (even minor in the eyes of the adult) and is accompanied by visible distress.
The emotional state of the child in crisis is clearly negative. It may involve anger, sadness, fear, frustration, or a mix of these emotions. The face is expressive: crying, screaming, expressions of rage or despair. The whole body bears the mark of the emotion.
The crisis has an identifiable beginning, even if the trigger may seem disproportionate compared to the reaction. A remark, a refusal, a difficulty, a perception of injustice preceded the overflow. The child was not in this state just a few minutes earlier.
During the crisis, the child is not very accessible to reasoning. Their cognitive abilities are overwhelmed by emotion. Explanations, requests for calm, threats of consequences generally have no effect or worsen the situation.
The intensity of the crisis can vary: from silent crying to an explosion of rage with screams, hits, and breaking objects. But in all cases, emotional suffering is at the forefront.
The mechanisms of the emotional crisis
The emotional crisis results from the emotional dysregulation characteristic of ADHD, amplified by a triggering event that exceeds the child’s tolerance threshold.
The prefrontal cortex, normally responsible for modulating emotions, is less effective in the ADHD child. The amygdala, which generates emotional responses, is not sufficiently regulated. Emotion expresses itself in a raw manner, without the filter that would contain it.
The deficient working memory prevents the child from mobilizing the regulation strategies they know. At the moment of the crisis, these resources are no longer accessible.
The accumulation of frustrations, fatigue, and sensory stimuli can lower the threshold for triggering crises. A child at the end of the day, after a difficult morning, will enter into a crisis over an event that would have had no effect at the beginning of the day.
The crisis is not a choice or a manipulation strategy. The child does not decide to lose control. They undergo an overflow that they cannot prevent with the resources they have at that moment.
How to respond to the emotional crisis
The response to the emotional crisis aims first to ensure safety, then to support the return to calm without worsening the distress.
During the crisis, the goal is not to educate or solve the problem but to contain it. Adopting a calm posture, lowering the level of stimulation, speaking little and with a calm voice, and not trying to reason with the child.
Ensure the physical safety of the child and others. If necessary, remove dangerous objects, have other students leave, protect the child from their own actions.
Remain present without being intrusive. The child needs to feel a reassuring presence but not to be overwhelmed by interventions. Stand nearby, available, without multiplying words or contact.
Wait for the emotional intensity to decrease before any educational intervention. The time for verbalization, analysis of what happened, and possible repair will come later, when the child has regained their cognitive abilities.
Do not punish the crisis itself. The child did not choose to lose control. Problematic behaviors that occurred during the crisis can be addressed later, with a learning objective rather than a punitive one.
—
Part Three: Opposition – the deliberate refusal
Recognizing opposition
Opposition is characterized by a conscious and deliberate refusal to conform to expectations or requests. Unlike the emotional crisis, the oppositional child maintains control over their means. They choose to say no, to resist, to contest.
The emotional state of the oppositional child can be relatively calm. They are not necessarily in distress. They may even seem satisfied with the situation, take pleasure in the power struggle, and display a certain provocation.
Opposition is targeted. The child refuses certain requests, coming from certain people, in certain contexts. They are not in a generalized refusal of everything. This selectivity indicates a certain level of cognitive control.
The oppositional child is accessible to communication, even if they refuse what is asked of them. They understand the instructions, can argue their position, and respond coherently. Their cognitive abilities are not overwhelmed.
Opposition can be passive (not doing what is requested) or active (doing the opposite, contesting, provoking). In both cases, it reflects a voluntary positioning rather than a loss of control.
The mechanisms of opposition
Opposition in the ADHD child can have several origins that should be distinguished.
It can be a reaction to an accumulation of frustrations. The child who feels constantly reprimanded, criticized, or misunderstood eventually develops a generalized attitude of resistance. Opposition becomes their way of regaining power in an environment experienced as hostile.
It can reflect a fragile self-esteem. The child who doubts their abilities sometimes prefers to refuse rather than risk failure. “I don’t want to” is less painful than “I can’t.” Opposition protects against the experience of incompetence.
It can be a learned strategy. If opposition has previously allowed avoiding unpleasant tasks or gaining attention, it tends to repeat. The child has learned that refusal “works” to obtain something.
It can also signal oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) associated with ADHD. This frequent comorbid disorder is characterized by a persistent pattern of negative, defiant, and hostile behaviors toward authority figures.
How to respond to opposition
The response to opposition aims to maintain the framework while avoiding escalation into a sterile power struggle.
Avoid frontal confrontation that risks reinforcing the opposition. The child who feels attacked in their autonomy will resist all the more. The power struggle is generally a lost cause.
Offering limited choices gives control back to the child within an acceptable framework. “Would you prefer to start with the math exercise or the French one?” provides some leeway while maintaining the work objective.
Use the redirection technique: instead of insisting on what the child refuses, guide them towards what they might accept. Offering an honorable way out avoids a deadlock.
Understand the function of opposition. What is the child seeking through this refusal? Attention? Avoiding an anxiety-provoking task? Regaining power? The answer will vary depending on the analysis.
Maintain logical consequences without entering into emotional confrontation. The tone remains calm, the consequence is applied as a logical outcome of the child’s choice rather than as a personal punishment.
Work on the relationship outside of conflict moments. A positive bond with the child is the best prevention against opposition. A child who feels respected and understood has less need to oppose.
—
Fourth part: Gray areas and combinations
When categories mix
In daily reality, behaviors are not always clearly categorized into one single category. Mixed situations are common and require fine analysis.
Agitation can evolve into an emotional crisis if the child is constantly reprimanded for their movement. The accumulation of frustrations related to reminders ends up exceeding the tolerance threshold, leading to overflow.
An emotional crisis may be followed by a phase of opposition. After the peak of distress, the child refuses to resume the activity, to apologize, to participate. This post-crisis opposition often reflects shame or fear of experiencing the same situation again.
Opposition can mask emotional vulnerability. A child who systematically refuses assessments may not be in a simple power struggle but in a protection against insurmountable performance anxiety.
Agitation can be a warning sign of a crisis. A sudden increase in activity level, a change in the quality of movement can signal an imminent overflow.
Observe to analyze
When faced with difficult behavior, a few questions can guide the analysis.
What is the child’s apparent emotional state? Calm, tense, in distress? Facial and body expressions provide valuable indications.
Was there an identifiable trigger? Did a specific event precede the behavior, or is it the child’s usual state?
Does the child maintain control over their means? Can they communicate coherently, answer questions, make choices?
Is the behavior targeted or generalized? Is the child refusing something specific or everything at once?
What is the evolution over time? Is the behavior stable, increasing, decreasing?
These observations help place the behavior on a continuum rather than in rigid boxes, and adapt the intervention accordingly.
The importance of context and history
The interpretation of behavior can only be done by considering the overall context.
What is happening at that moment of the day: fatigue, hunger, sensory overload, accumulation of frustrations influence the nature and intensity of behaviors.
The child’s recent history: have they experienced stressful events at home? Have they had conflicts with peers? Are they going through a difficult period?
The relational context: how is the relationship with the present adult? Does the child feel safe or threatened?
The child’s usual patterns: some children tend towards agitation, others towards emotional crises, others towards opposition. Knowing the usual profile helps interpret variations.
—
Fifth part: Adapting posture according to the type of behavior
Summary table of interventions
For agitation:
- Adult’s posture: tolerance and channeling
- Tone: neutral, benevolent
- Actions: offer alternatives, integrate movement, avoid excessive reminders
- Avoid: constant reprimands, demands for total stillness
For emotional crisis:
- Adult’s posture: containment and support
- Tone: calm, reassuring, few words
- Actions: ensure safety, reduce stimulation, wait for calm to return
- Avoid: reasoning, punishing, confronting
For opposition:
- Adult’s posture: benevolent firmness and non-confrontation
- Tone: calm, factual, without challenge
- Actions: offer choices, maintain logical consequences, work on the relationship
- Avoid: power struggle, escalation, personalization of conflict
Consistency within the team
For interventions to be effective, consistency among adults working with the child is essential.
Sharing a common analysis framework allows everyone to “read” behaviors in the same way. Regular exchange times around each other’s observations refine this shared reading.
Harmonizing responses prevents the child from receiving contradictory messages. If agitation is tolerated by one teacher and severely reprimanded by another, the child cannot develop stable strategies.
The collective training of the educational team is a powerful lever for coherence. DYNSEO training allows teams to acquire common references and shared tools.
The training “ADHD Student: Advanced Strategies for Managing Impulsivity and Opposition in Class” precisely offers this analysis grid and these differentiated tools according to types of behaviors.
Discover the training
Training “Supporting Students with Learning Disorders”
Training “DYS Disorders: Identify and Adapt”
—
Part Six: Prevention as the Main Strategy
Reducing Triggers
Beyond responding to difficult behaviors, preventive work aims to reduce their frequency and intensity.
For restlessness, systematically integrating movement opportunities throughout the day and providing channeling tools limits the accumulation of motor tension.
For emotional crises, identifying triggering situations (transitions, difficult tasks, sensory overload) allows for adjustments or preparations. Maintaining a predictable and secure environment reduces the baseline stress level.
For opposition, nurturing the relationship and preserving the child’s self-esteem decreases the need for resistance. Offering spaces for autonomy and choice meets the need for control without resorting to refusal.
Adapted Digital Tools
The program COCO THINKS and COCO MOVES from DYNSEO contributes to prevention by providing a structure adapted to the functioning of children with ADHD.
The alternation between cognitive activities and physical breaks prevents the accumulation of motor tension. Short and engaging activities maintain attention without generating frustration from overly long tasks. Integrated positive reinforcement nurtures self-esteem.
Discover COCO THINKS and COCO MOVES
Building the Child’s Skills
In the long term, the goal is to help the child develop their own self-regulation abilities.
Learning to recognize their internal states allows them to identify warning signals before an overflow. “I feel like I’m starting to get upset” opens the possibility for preventive action.
Teaching regulation strategies suited to their profile gives them tools to mobilize. Breathing, movement, temporary withdrawal, and asking for help constitute a repertoire of alternative responses.
Valuing progress reinforces the motivation to use these strategies. Every situation where the child has succeeded in avoiding or limiting a difficult behavior deserves recognition.
—
Conclusion: A Fine Reading for Adjusted Responses
Differentiating restlessness, emotional crises, and opposition in the ADHD student is not an academic exercise. It is a practical skill that transforms the effectiveness of interventions and preserves the educational relationship.
Restlessness calls for tolerance and channeling. The emotional crisis calls for containment and support. Opposition calls for benevolent firmness and non-confrontation. Applying the same response to these three situations leads to failure.
This differentiation ability is acquired through training, observation, and reflection on one’s practice. It requires moving beyond automatic reactions to analyze what is truly happening with the child at that specific moment.
DYNSEO training supports professionals in developing this skill. Because a better-understood ADHD student is a better-supported student, and a better-trained teacher is a less exhausted teacher.
Beyond managing difficult behaviors, this fine reading of the child builds a relationship of trust and mutual respect. The child who feels understood in their real difficulties, rather than judged on appearances, develops the inner security that will gradually allow them to better self-regulate.
—
Article published on the DYNSEO blog – Specialist in cognitive support and training for education professionals
Keywords: ADHD behavior, restlessness, emotional crisis, opposition, behavior differentiation, classroom management, ADHD support, teacher strategies
