Medical emergencies and refusal of care: responding to an older person in France
An older person has worrying symptoms and pushes help away. A relative may feel caught between the need to act and the wish to respect the person’s answer. The first useful action is to obtain the appropriate help and explain the refusal, rather than decide alone whether the person can consent or whether force is justified.
This guide concerns the French care context. It offers a practical way to prepare a call, communicate and support the handover; it is not a universal treatment protocol. Calling emergency services and deciding whether a particular intervention can be performed are different questions. A diagnosis of dementia, an older age or an answer that others dislike does not automatically remove the person’s right to be involved.
1. Seek urgent advice without waiting for an examination at home
In France, call 15 for a medical emergency, or 112 for emergency assistance. Urgence 114 provides an accessible emergency route for people who are deaf, deafblind, hard of hearing or aphasic through the available text and digital arrangements. These numbers and this legal discussion concern France; outside France, use the local emergency pathway and applicable rules.
Major breathing difficulty, loss of consciousness, suspected stroke or serious bleeding are examples requiring an immediate emergency response. Sudden confusion also needs urgent medical help. Do not rely on this short list to decide that another situation is safe. When concerned about urgency, describe the situation to the appropriate service and follow its advice.
Possible stroke signs include sudden face weakness, arm weakness or speech difficulty. Seek emergency help even if the signs have stopped. Do not wait until the person agrees to a blood-pressure reading or completes a cognitive test. A missing measurement does not prevent you from reporting what you observe.
In an illustrative situation, Farid suddenly struggles to speak and pushes away a relative trying to put on a cuff. The relative calls for emergency help, explains the new speech difficulty and says that he is refusing contact. They do not spend several minutes obtaining a reading before making the call.
A person who shouts or resists may still be seriously unwell. Do not treat their ability to make noise as proof that breathing, awareness or circulation is adequate. Conversely, quietness or reduced movement should not be celebrated as successful calming when it may represent deterioration. Describe the actual change to the service.
Keep yourself safe and follow the dispatcher’s instructions. Do not attempt an examination, transfer or treatment beyond your competence to make the report more complete. If the situation changes during the call, say so immediately. The professional can guide the next action using the information available.
2. Describe the refusal as part of the emergency call
Give the exact location and the information the service requests, including access details. In a residence, identify the building, floor and any entry arrangement clearly. If someone else can meet responders without leaving necessary support unattended, agree that task. Do not assume a location service can replace a clear address.
Describe what happened, when the change began and what is different from usual. Distinguish an observation from a diagnosis. Farid cannot form words as he normally does is more useful than he is having another behavioral episode. If the time is uncertain, say that rather than inventing precision.
Explain the refusal in concrete terms: the person says no, pulls away, will not answer or does not want to be touched. Mention any immediate safety concern. Avoid labelling them dangerous, incapable or non-compliant as a substitute for describing the situation. Those labels can obscure both the health concern and what support may be needed.
Share relevant known conditions, medicines and allergies when asked, including a Parkinson’s regimen if applicable. If information is unavailable, be honest and obtain it when possible without delaying the response. Do not use a familiar diagnosis to explain away a new change or decide that the service already knows what is happening.
State what has already been done and any instructions already received. A second caller should not give a conflicting account based only on what someone else thinks happened. Where several people are present, choose one person to communicate clearly with the service while others undertake agreed tasks if appropriate.
Stay on the call as directed and ask if an instruction is unclear. Follow current advice rather than a remembered response to a previous event. If the person declines the proposed action, tell the dispatcher. The refusal is information that affects the response, not a reason to end contact or improvise a coercive solution.

3. Keep consent and the French decision framework distinct from urgency
French law recognizes the right to refuse treatment and requires free, informed consent, which can be withdrawn. A life-threatening situation does not by itself prove that someone is unable to express their wishes. The clinical team must assess the actual situation and applicable framework; a relative should not announce that urgency cancels every refusal.
Article L1111-4 provides a specific process when a person’s refusal endangers their life, including information about consequences, reiteration within a reasonable period and documentation. When a person cannot express their wishes, consultation requirements and emergency or impossibility exceptions apply. These provisions do not give relatives a general authority to force treatment.
A dementia diagnosis or communication difficulty is not enough to conclude that a person cannot decide. Help them receive information and express a response through suitable means. Professionals need to consider what is understood and expressed in the actual situation. Disagreement with the recommended option is different from being unable to participate.
A personne de confiance can support an adult if wanted and, when the person cannot express their wishes, provide testimony about those wishes under the relevant rules. That role is different from a contact to notify and is not a blanket power to consent to every treatment. Tell the team about an existing designation without presenting it as universal authority.
Legal protection measures also differ in scope. Do not assume every guardian, relative or person managing finances has the same health-decision role. Show the relevant documentation to the team where available. They can identify the applicable process, including the person’s involvement, rather than asking the family to settle the issue by agreement among themselves.
Specific rules can apply to particular care and to end-of-life decisions. Inform the team of known advance directives or existing care arrangements and where documents can be found. Do not interpret them alone as an instruction either to do everything or to do nothing. Urgent assessment and the relevant professional decision process remain necessary.
4. Communicate while help is arranged, without promising safety you cannot guarantee
Use a short explanation of what is happening and who you are. A familiar person may help if their presence is wanted and the situation permits it. Several people speaking at once can make the exchange harder. Ask others to reduce unnecessary noise rather than crowding the person with repeated requests for agreement.
Choose truthful wording. You can say that you have called for medical help and that the team will explain the next step. Do not promise that nothing is wrong, that there is no risk or that nothing will hurt. Reassurance should not depend on information you do not have.
Ask before touching when possible and listen to the response. Announcing a gesture is useful but does not create consent on its own. A choice between the right and left arm is not a genuine way to ask whether the examination is accepted. The person must be able to communicate no as well as choose between options.
Do not require eye contact or assume silence means agreement. Use established hearing, vision or communication supports where relevant and safe. A picture, written word or familiar gesture may assist, but none proves comprehension automatically. Explain those communication needs to responders so the person does not have to start from the beginning repeatedly.
In Farid’s example, the relative says that medical help has been called and stays available without repeating demands for a measurement. They do not distract him with a song so that another person can secretly apply the cuff. A pleasant subject should not be used to conceal an unwanted procedure.
Communication support can happen alongside the call and clinical response. It should not become a sequence that has to succeed before help is requested. There is no rule that a person must first calm down, answer a set of questions or accept a drink before an emergency team can be told about the concern.
5. Avoid turning familiar care tasks into a misleading urgency category
A refused wash, medicine, dressing or meal cannot be classified as harmless from its name alone. The timing and consequences depend on the actual situation. Non-urgent personal care may be paused and reviewed, while missed or delayed medication can require prompt advice. Ask the responsible professional rather than apply a fixed waiting period.
If a usual medicine is refused or cannot be taken as prescribed, seek the relevant clinical or pharmacy advice. Do not give an extra dose later, crush tablets, hide medicine in food or substitute a preparation yourself. Some regimens, including Parkinson’s treatment, need particular attention to continuity and timing.
After a fall or suspected injury, follow emergency or professional guidance. Do not insist that the person stand up to prove they are uninjured, or improvise lifting because they refuse assessment. The dispatcher needs to know the event, symptoms and any known risks. Necessary action should be guided by the actual situation and competence available.
Do not offer food or drink as a universal calming step, especially when swallowing or alertness is impaired. If the person is choking or has major breathing difficulty, seek emergency help and follow instructions. A new preference for a different drink does not resolve an acute health concern.
If there is an immediate threat to someone’s safety, obtain appropriate emergency assistance and protect yourself. This article does not teach restraint or authorize relatives to immobilize a person. Any clinical restriction or medication decision requires the appropriate professional framework, assessment and safeguards; it is not a technique to learn from an online checklist.
For an ordinary care refusal without urgent symptoms, explain, listen and consider an appropriate alternative or later opportunity with the person. Repeated concerns should reach the responsible team. Respectful postponement is not abandonment, but postponing a task is different from leaving a potentially serious medical change unassessed.

6. Help responders receive the person and the relevant information
Prepare access if you can do so safely. Clear the route and manage an animal or locked entrance where appropriate. Do not leave someone who needs immediate support merely to organize the room. If more than one helper is available, divide practical tasks clearly so the emergency response is not delayed by confusion at the entrance.
On arrival, give a concise handover: the new symptoms, timing, usual state and refusal. Mention communication supports, sensory needs and what the person has said they want. A life history may be valuable later, but responders first need the information relevant to the immediate assessment.
Make current medicine and allergy information available through the appropriate record or list. Present documents such as a personne de confiance designation, protection measure or advance directives if known and available. Say if a document may be outdated. Do not use uncertainty as a reason to withhold the information or claim a status you have not checked.
Allow the person to communicate directly with the team as far as possible. A relative can supplement an account without answering every question on the person’s behalf. Ask the team how to assist, including whether familiar support should remain nearby. Do not assume your presence always helps or that your absence is automatically required.
In Farid’s example, the relative describes the speech change and the refused cuff, then tells the team how he normally communicates. They do not say he refuses everything or instruct responders to ignore his answer. The team receives the clinical concern and the communication problem as separate information.
If a proposed action is unclear, ask for an explanation without obstructing necessary urgent work. The person’s privacy and dignity continue to matter during an emergency. Limit unnecessary onlookers and avoid filming or sharing the encounter as a family update. A useful handover does not require a public record of a vulnerable moment.
7. Record the event after immediate needs have been addressed
Documentation should describe the event, response and remaining questions. It comes after requesting the help needed in the moment. A family note and a professional care record have different roles, and neither replaces the clinical team’s documentation of assessment and decisions. Do not present a personal diary as proof of legal compliance.
Use observable language. Record the person’s words or actions, the new symptoms and the relevant context. Distinguish what you witnessed from what someone else reported. Avoid explanations such as refuses because of dementia unless a qualified assessment supports that conclusion and the wording is relevant to the care record.
Include whom you contacted, when, the instructions received and any subsequent change. If a detail is uncertain, mark it as uncertain. Do not reconstruct a precise sequence from guesswork to fill every field. The record should help the next person understand what is known and what remains to be clarified.
Document the person’s experience and questions where appropriate. They may remember feeling frightened, not understood or excluded. That information can inform a review even if the emergency response was necessary. Do not treat completion of transport or a procedure as evidence that the encounter was comfortable or the communication sufficient.
In an illustrative handover after assessment, the team receives the treatment information and the instructions that need follow-up. A worker checks who is responsible for the next action. The note does not simply say crisis resolved while leaving medication changes, observations or a requested review unassigned.
Share necessary information through the appropriate confidential route. Not every relative needs the full clinical account, and a group message is not an automatic extension of the care record. Follow the relevant arrangements and the person’s wishes. Useful continuity depends on the right information reaching the right people, not the widest possible distribution.
8. Prepare between events with a manageable information plan
Preparation can reduce uncertainty without guaranteeing that an emergency will be easy. Check that the current address, access instructions and emergency contacts are available to those who need them. In France, make the relevant emergency route clear, including accessible arrangements. Keep personal health details where they can be used appropriately rather than displayed to every visitor.
Maintain a current medication and allergy list with suitable professional help. Agree who updates it and how an older copy is removed from use. A neat emergency folder is less useful if it contains conflicting regimens. The person should be involved in the arrangement according to their wishes and needs.
Ask about existing care plans, advance directives and a personne de confiance if the person wishes to discuss them. These are conversations for a suitable time, not forms to force during distress. Check how documents can be found by the relevant professionals and what needs reviewing. Do not promise that signing one document settles every future care decision.
Make ordinary support more understandable. Ask how the person wants explanations, what touch is acceptable and what communication aid they use. Record only useful information within the appropriate process. Preferences can change, and a past agreement does not automatically authorize the same action at every future encounter.
In an institution, practise the process through a fictional scenario: a worker notices new symptoms, calls the correct service and provides a handover. Include a refusal and unclear information. The exercise should test responsibility and response, not teach staff to obtain compliance by a standard phrase.
Families may benefit from learning recognized first aid and discussing role limits with the care team. A written guide cannot supply practical competence or guarantee a particular response. No certificate, funding or course duration is promised here. Choose training for a concrete need and verify the actual provision before relying on it.
9. Review the response, support those involved and address harm
After the event, ask what follow-up is required and who will arrange it. Health advice, treatment instructions and practical support may all need attention. Do not assume returning home or appearing calmer means everything is settled. The person and the service need a clear account of what happens next.
Listen to the person’s view without turning the review into a test of gratitude or cooperation. They may have questions about a procedure, a journey or an interaction. Offer the appropriate route to an explanation. Where communication is difficult, use suitable support rather than asking only relatives to interpret what the person must have felt.
Review organizational issues separately from individual blame. Was urgent help delayed by waiting for an internal manager? Was the current medication list available? Did staff know how to report a refusal? Choose a specific change, assign responsibility and check it is implemented rather than conclude that everyone simply needs to stay calmer.
If there was injury, suspected mistreatment or another serious concern, use the appropriate clinical, safeguarding or reporting route without waiting for a routine discussion where safety is at risk. This guide does not decide liability or replace the relevant investigation. A local review should not silence a person who wants to raise a concern.
Care partners and staff may need support after a frightening encounter. Arrange appropriate relief or professional help where needed. The person receiving care should not be made responsible for repairing everyone’s distress by becoming more compliant. Support for all involved can include clear roles, realistic staffing and access to advice.
The next useful step is to check the urgent contact pathway and the information needed for one person. Keep the distinction clear: obtain appropriate help promptly, communicate honestly and let the responsible professionals apply the relevant consent framework. That supports both timely care and the person’s continuing place in decisions about their health.
Resources for the next step
Explore respectful responses to refusal
Use learning to prepare questions about explanation, choice and role limits. It does not authorize force or replace the French legal and clinical assessment of a particular situation.
Prepare a concise handover
Record necessary observations, contacts and follow-up after immediate needs are addressed. A routine entry is not the emergency call itself.
Consider an accessible communication support
Check the person’s usual method and confirm meaning. A picture selection, silence or eye contact does not establish consent automatically.
Discuss an existing response pathway
Use a support to organize questions with the team. It is not a complete triage tool and cannot rule out an emergency.
To use these resources
Scenario for a team discussion: new speech difficulty appears, the person refuses a cuff and a worker calls for urgent help while reporting both facts. The review checks the call, communication and handover rather than whether the worker obtained the measurement first.
Frequently asked questions
No. Seek the appropriate urgent help and explain the refusal. Calling for assessment is distinct from deciding whether a specific intervention can be performed.
No. A diagnosis, age or communication difficulty does not establish inability to express wishes. Support communication and let professionals assess the actual situation and applicable framework.
No blanket rule applies. French law protects consent and refusal and provides specific processes and exceptions. The clinical team must apply them to the situation; relatives do not gain a general power to force treatment.
Do not assume that. Seek advice about the actual medicine and circumstances, especially for time-sensitive regimens. Do not alter, hide, crush or compensate doses yourself.
Useful items include current medication and allergy information, access details, communication needs and the location of relevant care documents. Keep responsibilities and urgent contacts clear without collecting unnecessary private information.
Choose a useful next step
Check the French urgent contact route and the information needed for a clear handover. Discuss communication and decision-making arrangements with the person and responsible team before a crisis makes those questions harder.
Did this content help you? Support DYNSEO 💙
We are a small team of 14 people based in Paris. For 13 years, we have been creating free content to help families, speech therapists, care homes and healthcare professionals.
Your feedback is the only way we know if our work is useful. A Google review helps us reach other families, caregivers and therapists who need it.
One action, 30 seconds: leave us a Google review ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐. It costs nothing, and it changes everything for us.
